reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000
- Summer reality TV
- Top Chef Wisconsin
- Below Deck
- American Ninja Warrior
Why is The Real CSI: Miami so uninterested in, uh, forensic science?
The Real CSI: Miami's first cases aren't set in Miami, and it gives barely any attention to evidence and forensic science. What a missed opportunity—YEEEEEEEAAAAAHH!
How are Below Deck Med’s Iain and Jono this bad at their jobs?
The problem with Top Chef’s finale is a major problem with all reality TV
30 For 30’s Stanley Cup riot episode doesn’t score
How much true crime is on Donald Sutherland’s c.v.?
jump to → latest stories • recommended TV • new comments • recent reviews
The Digest
A mini-blog of news, links, and updates
❑Wednesday, Jun. 26, 11:52 am | Andy Dehnart
Survivor 45 jury member Drew Basile is currently doing much better on Jeopardy!, winning $91,283 over five games.
He'll be back on tonight, Wednesday; Jeopardy's website has stats for all his games so far.
During Tuesday's episode, Ken Jennings passed along a message from Jeff Probst—former Rock 'N' Roll Jeopardy! host—to Drew, saying "he has heard about your success on the show and was so excited" and "he was amazing on our show."
❑Monday, Jun. 24, 1:07 pm | Andy Dehnart
The Real World Miami cast member Sarah Becker died last week by suicide at age 52. (If you're depressed, struggling, need help, or just want to talk to someone, please call or text 988 right now.)
During her season, Sarah memorably adopted a puppy, Leroy, and hoisted Flora up to look through a window at the threesome between Mike, Melissa, and another woman, causing the window to shatter.
When the show premiered, MTV's bio for Sarah said this:
A graduate of Indiana University, Sarah is an editor at one of the country's leading comic book companies in La Jolla, Calif. This self-admitted "19-year-old trapped in a 25-year-old body" loves to skateboard, collect empty Blistex tubes and Swatch watches, and spend her free time dressing up as television characters. A tomboy, Sarah says she doesn't deal well with pettiness and wants to stay true to herself while on the show.
❑Monday, Jun. 17, 9:32 am | Sarah D. Bunting
Attributing its ranking of the 30 best true-crime podcasts to "Staff Author" is pretty bogus of Entertainment Weekly -- but Ms. Author came up with a solid list nevertheless: a couple of surprises, a top choice I agree with, and some new listens for the "someday" section of my review list.
❑Sunday, Jun. 16, 1:12 pm | Andy Dehnart
Kenya Moore was suspended indefinitely from The Real Housewives of Atlanta, which is now filming.
Straight from the A first reported that "network execs recently called a full cast meeting and Moore received some very bad news as she was reportedly told she was INDEFINITELY SUSPENDED from filming after an internal investigation" because she "revealed explicit images of fellow cast member Brit Eady performing a sex act."
Kenya wrote on social media, "I would never engage in revenge p*rn, I have never distributed private images or footage of anyone, nor solicited images owned by others to use to threaten or blackmail. I have always been vindicated. I can’t talk about STORY even with people planting fake news."
❑Friday, Jun. 14, 9:01 am | Sarah D. Bunting
Ariana Grande went on Penn Badgley's podcast, Podcrushed, and talked about Quiet on Set and her own experience in the Nick-verse. This quote about kids trying to please the grown-ups and get that laugh dopamine really struck me: "Grande said young stars arehyper-focused on reactions to their performances from from adults on set which 'create a strange pattern that occurs where it’s really taking advantage of how much it means to the young performer to get a laugh from Video Village.'"
❑Wednesday, Jun. 12, 9:09 pm | Andy Dehnart
Chopped’s June 11 episode featured its first all-out, all-queer judging panel in the Food Network show's history: Tiffany Faison, Ginger Minj, and Gabe Bertaccini, plus, of course, out host Ted Allen.
Tiffany Faison posted on Instagram and said "I am so so grateful to have been a part of this day. Y’all this is special, it has NEVER happened before."
She also thanked Chopped producers Linda Lea and Amy Stanford "for pushing for so long to make this happen."
Chopped has been on TV since 2009 and has aired almost 800 episodes.
❑Wednesday, Jun. 12, 8:06 am | Sarah D. Bunting
According to Variety, a tearful Kevin Spacey told Piers Morgan he owes "millions" in legal fees, and is facing foreclosure on his Baltimore house. He also got passive-aggressive about Netflix and/or his House Of Cards co-stars supporting him: "It does seem with Dave Chappelle that Ted Sarandos has learned to be supportive of controversial individuals…I do wish he’d done that with me." Wow, what a shame that Spacey himself (allegedly) couldn't have avoided this nadir by treating others with respect in the first place!
❑Tuesday, Jun. 11, 12:30 pm | Sarah D. Bunting
Pamela Smart, whose story became To Die For as well as an HBO doc and more than one Law & Order episode, has finally admitted responsibility in an attempt to get her sentence reduced.
❑Tuesday, Jun. 11, 7:19 am | Andy Dehnart
My Below Deck Med season 9 episode 2 recap is coming soon, just later today, probably early afternoon.
It'll be worth the wait, I promise. Make yourself some sandwiches in the meantime.
❑Monday, Jun. 10, 7:58 pm | Andy Dehnart
Top Chef alum and guest judge Gregory Gourdet won the James Beard Award for best chef, northwest and Pacific.
This is his third James Beard Award in a row, having won previously for his cookbook and then his restaurant, kann.
Watch his acceptance speech, which Gregory posted on Instagram with a caption that said, in part:
Diversity and female led teams are not catch words but systems that work.
My hope is we can continue to work towards making our industry better for the next generation and even better for the one after that.
As we celebrate in excess and privilege remember that access to food is a basic human right and should never be used as a tool of war against the innocent.
Shows I recommend → The Dish with Kish • I Kissed a Boy
All of this week's premieres → Reality TV shows • reality TV specials and docs
Don't Miss → The reality show that changed TV • the Survivor cast contract • secrets of Amazing Race's first race
Latest stories
Why is The Real CSI: Miami so uninterested in, uh, forensic science?
The Real CSI: Miami’s first cases aren’t set in Miami, and it gives barely any attention to evidence and forensic science. What a missed opportunity—YEEEEEEEAAAAAHH!
Read More about Why is The Real CSI: Miami so uninterested in, uh, forensic science?
Top Chef is going to Canada, which already has Top Chef Canada
Top Chef announced its new location: Canada, home to poutine, maple syrup, and a show called Top Chef Canada. That won’t be confusing at all.
Read More about Top Chef is going to Canada, which already has Top Chef Canada
30 For 30’s Stanley Cup riot episode doesn’t score
Sorry for the lame pun…and here’s another: instead of knowing what it’s trying to say, “I’m Just Here for the Riot” freezes up.
Read More about 30 For 30’s Stanley Cup riot episode doesn’t score
How are Below Deck Med’s Iain and Jono this bad at their jobs?
Bosun Iain and chef Jono did more incomptence, while the Bri-Joe-Ellie triangle is heating up. My recap of Below Deck Med episode 4.
Read More about How are Below Deck Med’s Iain and Jono this bad at their jobs?
The problem with Top Chef’s finale is a major problem with all reality TV
“We found nothing” wrong with Danny’s finale meal, judge Gail Simmons said of Top Chef Wisconsin’s finale. The problem was editors “swung it too far” to create a suspenseful ending—and that’s led to both confusion and awful behavior.
Read More about The problem with Top Chef’s finale is a major problem with all reality TV
How much true crime is on Donald Sutherland’s c.v.?
(Not counting how criminal it is that Sutherland, who died last week, never got an Oscar nomination.) We’re running the BET-CRP numbers on his genre work.
Read More about How much true crime is on Donald Sutherland’s c.v.?
Hotel Cocaine is a defanged Casino
Hotel Cocaine somehow manages to make disco era Miami kind of colorless and dull.
Read More about Hotel Cocaine is a defanged Casino
Recent comments
Note for Jono's recipe card -- traditional gazpacho should not contain ginger (!!)
Well that sounds like absolute sh*t! I watch a few of the "murder shows" on ID and A&E and it is possible to tell the story and show investigations in an interesting way, without dumbing it down for…
Your article reminded me of the only real 'jaw dropping' experience I ever had on Top Chef was when the contestants had to cook in a gondola while it climbed to the top of I forget where. It…
As of yesterday, the court planned to hold the hearing today, but may not sentence him. Here's the docket update: TEXT ORDER as to ANDREW DRECHSEL. This matter comes before the Court sua sponte following receipt of Defendant's…
Any more updates on Drew Dreschel sentencing. Last I saw it was scheduled for today June 26, 2024.
Hello Andy, Was Port Protection's season 7 the last of the show? I'm going through withdrawal from Port P. I need another fix of it. Thanks, Terry (female)
Although I've never been there, from what I've seen, Canada is beautiful; I hope they go to a bunch of locations.
You're welcome—thanks for finding my sarcasm and stupidity funny!
This was my favorite recap! I was cackling all the way thru! Hilarious! Gael and Joe did get some help—from a small child who didn’t even have a face. Oh wait, maybe it was just blurred out because…
You can keep the ending suspenseful and still be fair with the editing. Like Colleen said, they had no problem showing Savannah was out of the running. I feel what the editors did was akin to a bait…
This is a good reminder that what we see in reality TV is not necessarily reality. I understand why they do it, but I wish they would stop trying to create stories sometimes. This episode of Top Chef…
Thank you for this. It's very distressing to read the reactions from people who seem to believe that only individuals from specific demographics are good enough to honestly win these competitions. Weak editing, with whatever is behind it,…
I'm going to be very happy to say Mary was the best. She has a heart of gold .Also I am very sad that Gary passed away he made me laugh and I loved his spirit for life.…
The bummer with the editing of the finale is we never got to hear and appreciate what was great about his dishes. Thanks Andy. Appreciate your reviews.
My disappointment with this Top Chef editing, perhaps to hide/disguise who won for effect or whatever, is that they had no problem whatsoever making it clear Savannah had lost. So that was weird.
Recent reality TV reviews
Why is The Real CSI: Miami so uninterested in, uh, forensic science?
Kristen Kish is the best part of Top Chef Wisconsin
I Kissed a Boy is a fabulously gay Love Island
The Big Bakeover is a sweet makeover show led by a Bake-Off winner
Queer Planet: a nature doc that has a gay old anthropomorphizing time
The Quiz with Balls takes way too long to drop
true crime from Best Evidence
Where Texas Monthly’s Hit Man ends, Richard Linklater’s Hit Man begins
You’ve watched Lover, Stalker, Killer. What now?
Devil On The Web and Web Of Make Believe: two takes on cybercrime
Get updates
Join other thoughtful and curious reality TV fans who get my reality TV reviews, recommendations, and analysis delivered to your inbox most Fridays:
Deep dives
Amazing Race behind the scenes
Trading Spaces
What happened behind the scenes
The Mole
An oral history of the Anderson Cooper and ABC years
try one of these shows
Alex vs America: Alex Guarnaschelli competes in a Food Network show worthy of her talent
Penguin live feeds, Party Down, and other charming things to watch
Tournament of Champions 5 is back, strengthened by the qualifiers and past winners
“Television can be such a fabulous teacher”